The team includes All-CSAC honorees as well as Player of the Year, Defensive Player of the Year, Rookie of the Year, Coach of the Year, and All-Sportsmanship honorees. The student-athletes were nominated by their coaches and voted upon by the conference's four head coaches who were not permitted to vote for their own players.
Coach of the Year was awarded to Jack Crawford from Bryn Athyn College. This is the first CSAC Coach of the Year nod for Crawford who has numerous Coach of the Year awards at the high school level. In his third full season in charge, Crawford led the Lions back to the playoffs ultimately earning the #3 seed in the CSAC Men's Lacrosse Tournament.
Jamal White, Attack, Jr., 1st Team Attack - 52 points, 30 goals, 22 assists
Tim Ragan, LSM, Sr., 1st Team LSM - 20 points, 9 goals, 11 assists, 99 groundballs, 38 CTOs
Ryan Ovecka, SSD, Sr., 1st Team SSD - 15 points, 8 goals, 7 assists, 41 groundballs
Dylan Fesmire, Defense, Fr., 1st Team Defense - 18 groundballs, 22 CTOs, 3 goals, 1 assists, 4 points
2022-2023 All-CSAC Men's Lacrosse
Player of the Year: Mason Dennis, Rosemont
Defensive Player of the Year: Cody Dembski, Keystone
Rookie of the Year: Cody Dembski, Keystone
Coach of the Year: Jack Crawford, Bryn Athyn
FIRST TEAM
| NAME | SCHOOL | YR | POSITION | HOMETOWN / HIGH SCHOOL |
| Jonathan Balsamo | Cairn | Jr. | Attack | Long Island, NY / Eastport South Manor |
| Navarro Blakes | Rosemont | Jr. | Attack | PG County, MD / Northwestern HS |
| Jamal White | Bryn Athyn | Jr. | Attack | Philadelphia, PA / Springfield Township HS |
| Mason Dennis | Rosemont | Gr. | Midfielder | North Wales, PA / Frankford HS |
| Ryan Smith | Keystone | FY | Midfielder | Warrington, PA / Central Bucks South |
| Greg Wever | Rosemont | Jr. | Midfielder | Leesburg, VA / Loudoun Valley HS |
| Cody Dembski | Keystone | FY | Face Off / Midfield | Agoura Hills, CA / Agoura HS |
| Tim Ragan | Bryn Athyn | Sr. | Long Stick Mid | Philadelphia, PA / New Foundations Charter |
| Ryan Ovecka | Bryn Athyn | Sr. | Short Stick Defense | Philadelphia, PA / Father Judge HS |
| Dylan Fesmire | Bryn Athyn | FY | Defense | Hatboro, PA / Hatboro-Horsham HS |
| Angel Rodriguez | Keystone | Sr. | Defense | Islip, NY / Islip HS |
| Qion Roycroft | Cairn | So. | Defense | Baltimore, MD / Woodlawn HS |
| Nico Cione | Cairn | So. | Goalie | Yardley, PA / Pennsbury HS |
ALL-SPORTSMANSHIP TEAM
| NAME | SCHOOL | YR | HOMETOWN / HIGH SCHOOL |
| Aaron Clark | Bryn Athyn | Sr. | Philadelphia, PA / Philadelphia Academy Charter |
| Adain Holliday | Cairn | FY | Manhattan, NY / Murry Bergtraum HS |
| Noah Lance | Keystone | Jr. | Scranton, PA / Scranton HS / PA Cyber |
| Mason Dennis | Rosemont | Gr. | North Wales, PA / Frankford HS |