Bryn Athyn College placed 32 student-athletes on the All-Academic Team.
| NAME | SPORT | MAJOR(S) | CLASS | HOMETOWN |
| Haybert Louchie | Men's Basketball | Mathematics/Computer Science | Senior | Long Pond, Pa |
| Nasir Mosley | Men's Basketball | Mathematics | Senior | Tobyhanna, Pa |
| Dante Lanzetta | Men's Basketball | Education | Senior | Howell, NJ |
| Isaiah Cureton | Men's Basketball | Psychology | Junior | Princeton, NJ |
| Alexis Mitchem | Women's Basketball | Pyschology | Senior | Trenton, NJ |
| Reilly Ward | Women's Basketball | Undecided | Freshman | Conway, S.C. |
| Rafe Williams | Men's Volleyball | Mathematics | Freshman | Bryn Athyn, Pa. |
| Teagan Dewees | Men's Volleyball | Building Arts | Junior | Bryn Athyn, Pa. |
| Magnus Lawing | Men's Volleyball | Undecided | Freshman | Jenkintown, Pa. |
| Chris Matera | Men's Volleyball | Human Society | Junior | Delran, NJ |
| Karl Cranch | Men's Volleyball | Business | Sophomore | Bryn Athyn, Pa. |
| Reid Schroeeder | Men's Volleyball | Mathematics | Freshman | Urbandale, Ia |
| Blake Halterman | Men's Volleyball | Mathematics/Computer Science | Sophomore | Bryn Athyn, Pa. |
| Payton Gormley | Women's Lacrosse | Education | Senior | Huntingdon Valley, Pa |
| Shea Gormley | Women's Lacrosse | Biology | Freshman | Huntingdon Valley, Pa |
| Lee Antwi | Women's Lacrosse | Biology | Junior | North Brunswick, N.J. |
| Maria Storck | Women's Lacrosse | Communications | Freshman | Philadelphia, Pa |
| Paulina Storck | Women's Lacrosse | Education | Senior | Philadelphia, Pa |
| Tori Titano | Women's Lacrosse | Education | Senior | Elkins Park, Pa |
| Ashley Rivera | Women's Lacrosse | Education | Senior | Southampton, Pa |
| Nicole McCurdy | Women's Lacrosse | Biology | Sophomore | Bryn Athyn, Pa. |
| Gabby Lang | Women's Lacrosse | Education | Junior | Clifton Heights, Pa. |
| Katherine Halle | Women's Lacrosse | Biology | Junior | Hillsborough, N.J. |
| Kalie Soulsby | Women's Lacrosse | Education | Junior | Yardley, Pa. |
| Kayla Poll | Women's Lacrosse | Education | Sophomore | Bensalem, Pa. |
| Colin O'Hara | Men's Lacrosse | Business | Junior | Bryn Athyn, Pa. |
| Winston Roth | Men's Lacrosse | Business | Freshman | Bryn Athyn, Pa. |
| Shane Avelar | Men's Lacrosse | Undecided | Freshman | Kutchner, Ontario |
| Michael Nabozny | Men's Lacrosse | Business | Freshman | Alpha, N.J. |
| Annae Connelly | Women's Tennis | Business | Freshman | Huntingdon Valley, Pa |
| Thea Keal | Women's Tennis | Undecided | Freshman | Huntingdon Valley, Pa |
| Ava Fino | Women's Tennis | Biology | Freshman | Harding, Pa. |