Owen Ovecka | All-CSAC 2nd Team - The captain midfielder got a second team nod after being tied for second in goals on the team with 5 and registering 1 assist for 11 points. Ovecka has been a mainstay in the midfield for Lions logging the third most minutes on the team.
Vincent Buccafuri | All-CSAC Honorable Mention - Buccafuri has been an achor for the Lions defensive unit. The imposing centerback has been a steady presence for the Lion on the backline helping the Lions have a top 4 defense in the conference. Buccafuri has logged the second most minutes on the team.
Justin Lykunov | All-CSAC Honorable Mention - Lykunov got the nod for honorable mention after showing the value he brings as a connecting forward. Lykunov logged 2 goals in his debut campaign. He generated many chances and stretched the defense to open up play for the Lions offensively.
Brandon Cruz | All-Sportsmanship - Cruz received the All-Sportsmanship bid for the Lions.
| 2021 All-CSAC Men's Soccer | ||||
| 2021 CSAC Player of the Year: Kaiden Fields, Rosemont College | ||||
| 2021 CSAC Defensive Player of the Year: Kameron Clark, Cairn University | ||||
| 2021 CSAC Rookie of the Year: Jesse Brittain, Cairn Universiy | ||||
| 2021 CSAC Coach of the Year: John Loiodice, Rosemont | ||||
| 2021 CSAC 3-D Award: Cairn University | ||||
| First-Team All-CSAC | ||||
| Pos | Name | School | Cl. | Hometown/High School |
| D | Josh Goodyear | Cairn | Sr. | Camp Hill, Pa./Camp Hill |
| D | William Boehmer | Rosemont | Sr. | Downingtown, Pa./Downington West |
| D | Ibrahim Bangoura | Keystone | So. | Jersey City, N.J./Manhattan College |
| D | Tai Torres | Rosemont | Fr. | Staten Island, N.Y./Monsignor Farrell |
| F | Jesse Brittain | Cairn | Fr. | Chester, Pa./The Christian Academy |
| F | Kaiden Fields | Rosemont | So. | Orlando, Fla. |
| F | Axel Gonzalez | Keystone | Jr. | Bernardsville, N.J./Bernards |
| GK | Kameron Clark | Cairn | Sr. | Ewing, N.J./Ewing High School |
| MF | Moses Beers | Cairn | Fr. | Lancaster, Pa./Manheim Township |
| MF | Alexander Arriola | Rosemont | Jr. | Fairlawn, N.J./Fairlawn |
| MF | Ian Dolan | Rosemont | Fr. | Cherry Hill, N.J./Cherry Hill West |
| MF | Micah Portis | Cairn | Sr. | Abington, Pa./Abington |
| Second-Team All-CSAC | ||||
| Pos | Name | School | Cl. | Hometown/High School |
| D | Hunter Keaton | Cairn | Sr. | New Egypt, N.J./New Egypt |
| D | Erik Duran | Keystone | So. | Marietta, Ga./Kennesaw Mountain |
| D | Justin Olbrich | Rosemont | Fr. | Woodstown, N.J./Woodstown |
| D | Steven Maia | Saint Elizabeth | Fr. | Newark, N.J./Eastside |
| F | Clayton Crosse | Rosemont | Fr. | Washington Township, N.J./Washington Twp. |
| F | Miguel Aristizabal | Saint Elizabeth | Jr. | Clifton, N.J./Clifton |
| F | Brandon Hasko | Cairn | Gr. | Pitman, N.J./Pitman |
| GK | Todd Berman | Rosemont | So. | Springfield, Pa./Springfield |
| MF | Danny Kellerman | Clarks Summit | Fr. | Cape Town, South Africa/Sinton |
| MF | Hernan Godoy | Keystone | Fr. | Bernards, N.J./Bernards |
| MF | Owen Ovecka | Bryn Athyn | Jr. | Philadelphia, Pa./Father Judge |
| MF | Kevin Ventura De Sousa | Rosemont | Fr. | Voorhees, N.J./Eastern High School |
| Honorable Mention All-CSAC | ||||
| Pos | Name | School | Cl. | Hometown/High School |
| D | Easton Shelley | Cairn | Jr. | Elkton, Md./Elkton High School |
| D | Vincent Buccafuri | Bryn Athyn | So. | Ambler, Pa./Hatboro-Horsham |
| D | Jackson Cordell | Wilson | Fr. | Waynesboro, Pa./Waynesboro |
| D | Justin Flores | Saint Elizabeth | So. | Hasbrouck Heights, N.J./Paramus Catholic |
| F | Matthew Pattison | Rosemont | So. | Cherry Hill, N.J./Bishop Eustace Prep |
| F | Ryder Wallace | Wilson | Jr. | Jim Thorpe, Pa./Jim Thorpe |
| F | Justin Lykunov | Bryn Athyn | Fr. | Feasterville, Pa./Neshaminy |
| GK | Kristian Figueroa | Clarks Summit | Fr. | Guaynabo, P.R./Wesleyan Academy |
| MF | David Sage | Clarks Summit | Fr. | Altavista, Va./Home School |
| MF | Jacob Flores | Saint Elizabeth | So. | Hasbrouck Heights, N.J./Paramus Catholic |
| MF | Alejandro Lopez | Saint Elizabeth | So. | Fulshear, Texas/Katy |
| MF | Ethan Mosquera | Saint Elizabeth | So. | Springfield, N.J./Jonathan Dayton |
| All-Sportsmanship | ||||
| Name | School | Cl. | Hometown/High School | |
| Brandon Cruz | Bryn Athyn | Sr. | Holland, Pa./Council Rock | |
| Josh Goodyear | Cairn | Sr. | Camp Hill, Pa./Camp Hill | |
| Jack Slusser | Clarks Summit | So. | Clarks Summit, Pa./Abington Heights | |
| Erik Duran | Keystone | So. | Marietta, Ga./Kennesaw Mountain | |
| Alexander Arriola | Rosemont | Jr. | Fairlawn, N.J./Fairlawn | |
| Luis Salazar | Saint Elizabeth | Sr. | Las Vegas, Nev./Valley | |
| Jordan Kieffer | Valley Forge | So. | Mohnton, Pa./Home Schooled | |
| Jorge Cortez | Wilson | Fr. | Columbia, Tenn./Spring Hill | |